An Analysis of The Celebrated Cases of Judge Dee
1. Assume the identity of a female character and describe what Judge Dee does and how you feel about him.
From a perspective of a female character, I think that I will not approve of what Judge Dee does. His quest for truth is commendable however, his means of extracting the truth is illegal thereby making his conduct unworthy of a Judges position. During the first parts of the story, his knowledge and dedication in the pursuit of justice is admirable but as the story goes on, it is not difficult to see that he is not as honorable as he thinks he is. In Chapter twenty seven of the book, Judge Dee tortured both a man and a woman in order to confess their adulterous relationship and connivance to murder the husband of the woman in order for them to be free for marriage. In his presence, the man and the women were successively made to lie down on their backs and to have their arms and legs be placed on screws. Every time they refuse to confess, Judge Dee would have the screws tightened up thereby crushing their bones and making them scream in agony (Hans Van Gulik).
However, some women might find him appealing because as harsh as he is, he can also be sensitive sympathizing and it is these characters that enable him to gain the trust of many people, more particularly those who are attractive and young women who find themselves in trouble. Torturing a person to extract a confession is illegal and as a judge, he must be aware that this process is not acceptable in the court of law. His focus in capturing a criminal made him blind to the principles that he must adhere to. Being a judge is not an excuse to commit a criminal act.
2. You are a Censor sent to check on Judge Dee. Make your report.
Censor is defined as one who supervises the conduct and morality of others ( Censor ). If I were a censor during the time of Judge Dee, I would give him a positive report but if this were today, I would have to make a note of my objections against some of his practices.
The Celebrated Cases of Judge Dee showed the background of the Tang Dynasty. The series of crimes that were solved by him allows the readers to follow the history of China. History shows that during the Tang Dynasty, the authoritative views of the Chinese were very strict. The authorities have a tight grip in their communities who knew the consequences of causing a crime. Judge Dee, together with his associates, begins to solve one crime after another using clever observations, underground sources, forensics and interrogation (Hans Van Gulik). Through Judge Dees behavior, the Asian influence can be aptly observed as he takes into consideration his religion, dreams and even ghosts in solving crimes. For the Chinese, judges must act as a father and a mother to the people by helping the sick and cherishing those who are good and loyal. More important is the fact that a judge must not lose sight in heeding justice. It is undeniable that Judge Dee puts more weight in the spirit of justice rather than the letter of the law and he is more geared towards alleviating the victims sufferings no matter what the cost.
I am of the firm view that one must be able to draw the line between what is acceptable in the eyes of the law and what is not. Justice is not only for the victims but also for the accused. Judge Dee, in solving his cases, went to great lengths in order to gather his evidence and I am indeed giving him a commendation about that. On the other hand, he often fail to take in to consideration the side of justice on the part of the accused.
In deciding what the censor must report one must consider the setting of the story. This book was written decades before and as such, the justice system may have been different then as it was today. His unconventional methods may have worked before but if these were done today, he would be facing administrative charges. Justice is not served every time he puts matters into his own hands in torturing a person into confessing their guilt. In todays court of law, any confession made by force, intimidation and duress would not be acceptable in the court of law and therefore, everything that Judge Dee accomplished would all be for naught.
3. If only Judge Dee were still alive and could deal with criminals today, we would all be much better off. What do you think
I am inclined to agree with this statement. In the book entitled The Celebrated Cases of Judge Dee, the unquenchable thirst of Judge Dee in his quest to find the truth in solving all his cases. Furthermore, Judge Dee is no ordinary Judge because all of his decisions are founded based on the morals of the Confucians and the Taoists. For these people, finding the truth is one of the most sacred duties that a Judge holds and there will befall a great dishonor upon any Judge who accidentally condemns a person who is not guilty. The book is also a great way to show the system of law enforcement being implemented by the Chinese people.
The sense of morality of the Chinese is deeply embedded in the book. They believe that a judge is a symbol of truth and justice. They are mandated by law to be loyal to the court and decide with all fairness and honesty using only the weight of evidence presented upon them. It is an extremely rare gift and a heavy responsibility to have the life of a person in ones hands and as such, a judge must carefully take into consideration all evidence submitted to him before making his verdict. As the saying goes, it is better to let go of a thousand guilty man than to convict an innocent one.
Judge Dee upheld equality when he said that in a tribunal, everybody is equal and there is no regard for any rank or position. This bold statement is rarely heard in todays society and it would make a big difference if only all of the judges would have the commitment and dedication of Judge Dee in making a fair and unbiased decision regardless of a persons social standing and influence. In the world today, power is everything. One may think that he can get away with doing what is legal because of some connections that has thereby creating inequality in the eyes of the law.
It is noteworthy to mention that the values that Judge Dee has was motivated by his belief in the values of Confucius. It was Confucius who taught the people the value of respect in order to maintain a peaceful society. There relationships are mainly dependent on superiority and inferiority. Those who are superior are not better than those whose positions are underneath them but in most cases, they are the ones who have more life experiences and responsibility. The followers of Confucianism believe that they each have a responsibility towards one another. It was Confucius who said that those who are superior are required to show mercy, goodness and wisdom while those who are inferior are bound to show obedience and respect. Due to the reciprocity of their responsibilities toward each other, the lower member is not obliged to do something bad even if it was their superior who instructed them to do such things. One of the golden teachings of Confucius is that the highest duty that a person has to himself and to the society is to do what they know is right.
One thing that particularly captured my attention is the fact that Judge Dee often exposes the offenders in public for the entire community to be reminded of the price that a criminal must pay. Through this, I cannot help but create a comparison of the Chinese and the American ethics. In China, they humiliate those who offended the crime while in America, every individual is considered innocent as proven guilty and they have the right to appeal. Torturing a guilty person is an effective way to elicit confession but torturing the innocent to force them to admit a crime that they did not commit is an entirely different thing. There is a great chance that these individuals would admit guilt because they could not bear the torture and pain any longer.
4. Assigning this book is a terrible idea. Professor Berring, never do it again. Why
Even though the detective stories capture the interest and attention of the readers, the detective stories of Judge Dee has become obsolete and can no longer be applied in real life. The criminal justice system has changed drastically over the years and as good as Judge Dee was, his means and ways are not suitable in application for today.
Judge Dee may have been good judge during his time and he may still be an effective one today but his power and authority may not be the same as that portrayed in the book. During the old times, it can be observed that people really showed reverence and fear to the authorities which is a good thing. Today, the perception and respect of the people towards judges are not the same as before. Furthermore, inhumane punishments such as death by strangulation are already forbidden by the
Constitution.
Therefore, it is recommended that the professors make the students read a book that is more realistic and more applicable for today. Judge Dee may tickle the minds of the readers but only to a certain extent because while reading the book, those raised in a western culture who know the procedures of the law may shrug their heads thinking how Judge Dee crossed the boundaries of legality in order to get the criminals. Reading the book gives a person a clear comparison and contrast of the Chinese and American culture and the one good thing that I think came out of this assignment is that I have learned to appreciate the fairness of the justice system of the westerns.
From a perspective of a female character, I think that I will not approve of what Judge Dee does. His quest for truth is commendable however, his means of extracting the truth is illegal thereby making his conduct unworthy of a Judges position. During the first parts of the story, his knowledge and dedication in the pursuit of justice is admirable but as the story goes on, it is not difficult to see that he is not as honorable as he thinks he is. In Chapter twenty seven of the book, Judge Dee tortured both a man and a woman in order to confess their adulterous relationship and connivance to murder the husband of the woman in order for them to be free for marriage. In his presence, the man and the women were successively made to lie down on their backs and to have their arms and legs be placed on screws. Every time they refuse to confess, Judge Dee would have the screws tightened up thereby crushing their bones and making them scream in agony (Hans Van Gulik).
However, some women might find him appealing because as harsh as he is, he can also be sensitive sympathizing and it is these characters that enable him to gain the trust of many people, more particularly those who are attractive and young women who find themselves in trouble. Torturing a person to extract a confession is illegal and as a judge, he must be aware that this process is not acceptable in the court of law. His focus in capturing a criminal made him blind to the principles that he must adhere to. Being a judge is not an excuse to commit a criminal act.
2. You are a Censor sent to check on Judge Dee. Make your report.
Censor is defined as one who supervises the conduct and morality of others ( Censor ). If I were a censor during the time of Judge Dee, I would give him a positive report but if this were today, I would have to make a note of my objections against some of his practices.
The Celebrated Cases of Judge Dee showed the background of the Tang Dynasty. The series of crimes that were solved by him allows the readers to follow the history of China. History shows that during the Tang Dynasty, the authoritative views of the Chinese were very strict. The authorities have a tight grip in their communities who knew the consequences of causing a crime. Judge Dee, together with his associates, begins to solve one crime after another using clever observations, underground sources, forensics and interrogation (Hans Van Gulik). Through Judge Dees behavior, the Asian influence can be aptly observed as he takes into consideration his religion, dreams and even ghosts in solving crimes. For the Chinese, judges must act as a father and a mother to the people by helping the sick and cherishing those who are good and loyal. More important is the fact that a judge must not lose sight in heeding justice. It is undeniable that Judge Dee puts more weight in the spirit of justice rather than the letter of the law and he is more geared towards alleviating the victims sufferings no matter what the cost.
I am of the firm view that one must be able to draw the line between what is acceptable in the eyes of the law and what is not. Justice is not only for the victims but also for the accused. Judge Dee, in solving his cases, went to great lengths in order to gather his evidence and I am indeed giving him a commendation about that. On the other hand, he often fail to take in to consideration the side of justice on the part of the accused.
In deciding what the censor must report one must consider the setting of the story. This book was written decades before and as such, the justice system may have been different then as it was today. His unconventional methods may have worked before but if these were done today, he would be facing administrative charges. Justice is not served every time he puts matters into his own hands in torturing a person into confessing their guilt. In todays court of law, any confession made by force, intimidation and duress would not be acceptable in the court of law and therefore, everything that Judge Dee accomplished would all be for naught.
3. If only Judge Dee were still alive and could deal with criminals today, we would all be much better off. What do you think
I am inclined to agree with this statement. In the book entitled The Celebrated Cases of Judge Dee, the unquenchable thirst of Judge Dee in his quest to find the truth in solving all his cases. Furthermore, Judge Dee is no ordinary Judge because all of his decisions are founded based on the morals of the Confucians and the Taoists. For these people, finding the truth is one of the most sacred duties that a Judge holds and there will befall a great dishonor upon any Judge who accidentally condemns a person who is not guilty. The book is also a great way to show the system of law enforcement being implemented by the Chinese people.
The sense of morality of the Chinese is deeply embedded in the book. They believe that a judge is a symbol of truth and justice. They are mandated by law to be loyal to the court and decide with all fairness and honesty using only the weight of evidence presented upon them. It is an extremely rare gift and a heavy responsibility to have the life of a person in ones hands and as such, a judge must carefully take into consideration all evidence submitted to him before making his verdict. As the saying goes, it is better to let go of a thousand guilty man than to convict an innocent one.
Judge Dee upheld equality when he said that in a tribunal, everybody is equal and there is no regard for any rank or position. This bold statement is rarely heard in todays society and it would make a big difference if only all of the judges would have the commitment and dedication of Judge Dee in making a fair and unbiased decision regardless of a persons social standing and influence. In the world today, power is everything. One may think that he can get away with doing what is legal because of some connections that has thereby creating inequality in the eyes of the law.
It is noteworthy to mention that the values that Judge Dee has was motivated by his belief in the values of Confucius. It was Confucius who taught the people the value of respect in order to maintain a peaceful society. There relationships are mainly dependent on superiority and inferiority. Those who are superior are not better than those whose positions are underneath them but in most cases, they are the ones who have more life experiences and responsibility. The followers of Confucianism believe that they each have a responsibility towards one another. It was Confucius who said that those who are superior are required to show mercy, goodness and wisdom while those who are inferior are bound to show obedience and respect. Due to the reciprocity of their responsibilities toward each other, the lower member is not obliged to do something bad even if it was their superior who instructed them to do such things. One of the golden teachings of Confucius is that the highest duty that a person has to himself and to the society is to do what they know is right.
One thing that particularly captured my attention is the fact that Judge Dee often exposes the offenders in public for the entire community to be reminded of the price that a criminal must pay. Through this, I cannot help but create a comparison of the Chinese and the American ethics. In China, they humiliate those who offended the crime while in America, every individual is considered innocent as proven guilty and they have the right to appeal. Torturing a guilty person is an effective way to elicit confession but torturing the innocent to force them to admit a crime that they did not commit is an entirely different thing. There is a great chance that these individuals would admit guilt because they could not bear the torture and pain any longer.
4. Assigning this book is a terrible idea. Professor Berring, never do it again. Why
Even though the detective stories capture the interest and attention of the readers, the detective stories of Judge Dee has become obsolete and can no longer be applied in real life. The criminal justice system has changed drastically over the years and as good as Judge Dee was, his means and ways are not suitable in application for today.
Judge Dee may have been good judge during his time and he may still be an effective one today but his power and authority may not be the same as that portrayed in the book. During the old times, it can be observed that people really showed reverence and fear to the authorities which is a good thing. Today, the perception and respect of the people towards judges are not the same as before. Furthermore, inhumane punishments such as death by strangulation are already forbidden by the
Constitution.
Therefore, it is recommended that the professors make the students read a book that is more realistic and more applicable for today. Judge Dee may tickle the minds of the readers but only to a certain extent because while reading the book, those raised in a western culture who know the procedures of the law may shrug their heads thinking how Judge Dee crossed the boundaries of legality in order to get the criminals. Reading the book gives a person a clear comparison and contrast of the Chinese and American culture and the one good thing that I think came out of this assignment is that I have learned to appreciate the fairness of the justice system of the westerns.